Book Review: Eerie by C.M. McCoy

When Hailey's older sister gets abducted and she too ends up in danger, Hailey gets sent off to Bear Towne University, a ParaScience school in The Middle of Nowhere, Alaska, the one place she might be safe because it turns out Asher, the creature from her dreams, is not only real but also the only one who can protect her. Unfortunately, he also sometimes wants to kill her---literally. But between yetis, dangerous in-betweens, poltergeists, her newfound and confusing love life, a roommate who's not human, and an evil immortal who wants her dead, that just might be the least of her worries.

Title: Eerie
Book Number: Book 1 of TBA
Pages: 434
My Rating: 3 Stars
More Info: Goodreads, Amazon


*I received a free ecopy of this book from the author in exchange for an honest review.*

There were some things I really liked about this book and some things, well, not so much, so… time for some lists!

Things I Liked:

1) The book was quirky and absurd and fun. I couldn’t help but crack up at some of it (especially the bits about Hailey’s clothes coming to life)!

2) Asher was adorable. Rather, his confusion in trying to understand and adapt to human ways and emotions was adorable. I know he was this big, scary monster, and he did some messed up things, but he wasn’t human, so that’s kind of to be expected. He was literally just learning what emotion was, how dating worked, etc. And some of the things he said and did, like replacing all of Hailey’s stuff and even getting her flowers and a book for the librarian, was touching and swoon-worthy.

3) Hailey’s friendship with Giselle was sweet. I loved the way Hailey never gave up, even when Giselle pushed her away, and ended up having a really great effect on Giselle.

4) The author has clearly put thought into the story. The backstory about the Envoys, Hailey’s connection to them, Fin’s background, etc. was a bit confusing at times but interesting and unique.

Things I Disliked:

1) The actions and reactions of characters required too much suspension of disbelief. Sometimes it was part of the absurd fun, but it bothered me that Hailey never really questioned it and that even people who weren’t connected to the paranormal didn’t act very believably.

2) I couldn’t get into the love triangle because I didn’t like Fin. I wanted to like him because he was sweet, playful, and there for Hailey sometimes, but he was a complete jerk other times. If you actually care about someone, you never treat them that way. He did have explanations sometimes, but there were other times when I didn’t see any valid excuse, like when Hailey got locked out of her room and he refused to open her door, leaving her to sleep in the hall all night. And all the times he went back and forth between hot and cold within a span of minutes. I know there were certain good things he did, but overall he seemed manipulative and dishonest. *SPOILER ALERT* Yes, the ending revealed certain things in his defense, but he still treated her poorly and lied about things, like how he was only bringing those girls back to his room to tell them it was over even though she saw him undressing one when they were still in the hallway. *END SPOILER ALERT* So for those reasons, I didn’t believe Fin’s feelings for Hailey or understand where her feelings for him came from. But I’m willing to concede that there may be more explanations I don’t know about yet.

Things I’m Unsure About:

1) Hailey was strong-minded and confident… sometimes. She stood up for herself to Asher when he got possessive, stood up to most things that got in her way actually, but she always let Fin get away with treating her badly. So I’m not sure how I feel about her character.

The Verdict:

As I said, the book was fun. And most of my issues boiled down to my dislike of Fin, but other readers may love him. So the positives outweighed the negatives enough for me to enjoy the book, though I think I may have liked it more if I actually were a teen rather than an adult who reads YA. But the ending really threw me for a loop! Even though I haven’t decided yet about continuing, it makes me think things will get even more interesting in the next book.


Book Tags:

Basic Info

Book Author:
Genre: , , ,
My Rating:

More Info (Possible Spoilers)

Non-Human Type:
Extra Love:


Talk to me!

Have you read Eerie by C.M. McCoy?
Do you like quirky, absurd books?


Your Thoughts


6 thoughts on “Book Review: Eerie by C.M. McCoy

I'd love if you'd share your thoughts, too!


Reading your comments makes me a very happy blogger!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Daniela Ark

    Glad to hear the positives outweighed the negatives and you enjoyed the book. Haha sorry I have to smile and that ending getting to you huh? 🙂 I don’t mind love triangles. I think they are so true for YAs. The problem is they have been so overused though that but of course you have to kinda like the characters to feel it. The triangle like everything else will at least be a sum of its parts 🙂
    Fin you ruined what could have been perfect geometry! 🙂

    1. Kristen Burns

      I couldn’t say much pertaining to the ending since it would been kinda spoiler-y, but yeah, it made me rethink some previous thoughts I had about the story.

      I actually do like love triangles in books, so it wasn’t the triangle I minded, just the Fin lol. As you said, love triangles are the sum of their parts, so just liking Asher wasn’t enough to make me like the whole triangle! But I suppose liking one of the characters is better than liking neither.

  2. AngelErin

    Great review! This one sounds really great, but I hate when I have to suspend my disbelief too much. I may still try this one at some point though. If you decide to read the next book I hope you like it even better. 😀

  3. Bookworm Brandee

    I like the way lists really help lay it all out, don’t you? I do like quirky and absurd books but there are limits in the suspension of disbelief. I agree with you on Fin – if you care about someone, you don’t treat them poorly…for any reason, really. And I also understand your divided feelings about Hailey. I don’t think people are strong-minded except for…. That doesn’t ring true in my mind. If that’s part of your character, it’s part of your character. I’m glad that you enjoyed the story overall, Kristen. It certainly seems quirky and absurd! And fun, too. 🙂

    1. Kristen Burns

      Sometimes lists are the only way to do it! I guess, in absurd books, my suspension of disbelief depends on how real the world is supposed to be/how realistic characters are supposed to be.

      It’s funny though because your comment about Hailey made me think about her in a way I hadn’t before. I suppose it’s actually not entirely unbelievable that someone would be strong-minded most of the time but make excuses for someone and let them get away with things simply because they care about that person and don’t want to lose them. But then… I don’t know. Now you have me all confused lol.