I’ve read this book twice, first the normal way some years ago, and I loved it, now the audiobook some years later, and I enjoyed it, but I didn’t feel all the emotions I felt the first time. But the difference in opinion could’ve been because I’ve gotten pickier, because of my mood, because I knew what to expect, or just because I didn’t love the narrator, so I’m struggling to decide how to rate and review this.
*Warning, if you really want absolutely nothing that could be considered a spoiler, don’t read this review, It mentions a couple things you don’t immediately find out (what type of supernatural one of the characters is, how the romance plays out). But I don’t consider them spoilers, and they’re things I was glad to know because they made me more interested.*
I didn’t review books back when I read this the first time, but I did keep personal notes, so here are some of those, verbatim from past Kristen:
“This book was so good! It was dark, intense, and emotional. The relationships between the characters, especially between Vance and Simon, were heart-wrenching. I loved it. AND THEN THAT SCENE WITH THE BOOKS. The characters were great—all different from each other, likeable. The plot wasn’t a major thing until late in the book, but I knew what the end goal was, and I wasn’t concerned with the general lack of plot because the book was VERY character-driven and focused on their emotions and relationships. The writing sucked me in and set the mood. The whole thing sucked me in.
“The one issue I had was the way the romance played out. It was enjoyable and tingly when Chris and Vance were getting to know each other and falling in love. It was heart-wrenching when I realized Vance and Simon both still loved each other. It was unbelievable though when suddenly Simon and Chris were also in love, and Simon and Vance were back in love, and everyone was in love. It was too sudden and too easy. It didn’t make any sense WHY Simon and Chris had these feelings for each other all the sudden.”
This second time around, I felt that, despite the bleak setting and situation the characters were in, this was a sweet, surprisingly not-dark, low-angst, polyamorous romance. (Really goes to show how the way you view things can change!) The characters had some minor hiccups in their relationship, but they found their way to love pretty easily. Some of Chris’s psychic powers were cool. There was a vampire, and I always like those! I had two real issues though. One, again, I didn’t fully feel the feelings between the men; it felt rushed and like they just ended up together because they were all each other had in that hell hole. And two, I felt like they could’ve escaped a lot sooner and easier had they just communicated better and made better decisions.
As for the audiobook, I can’t say I loved it (but do keep in mind I’m a very picky listener). I didn’t love the voices the narrator (Jack LeFleur) did for the characters, but it was easy to tell characters apart, and the non-dialogue narration parts were good.
Overall though, what past and present me seem to agree on is that the book had likeable characters, a nice M/M/M romance, and a good story!
*Although this is part of a series, it works perfectly well as a standalone, but I do recommend continuing (especially if you like Matt as much as I did) as I liked the second book even more and it ties up some loose ends.*
*I’ve read this book multiple times. This review was written after my 2nd read.*
4.5 Stars (1st read – 2016)
4 Stars (2nd read – 2020)
Anyone who likes M/M/M relationships, paranormal romance, and slow, character-driven books.
More Books in the Series:
Book Review: In Darkness Bound (The Society Book 1) by Christine Price [+ Audiobook]
Book Review: The Usual Apocalypse (The Society Book 2) by Christine Price [+ Audiobook]
This is one reason I don’t tend to reread books. I’m always afraid I’ll ruin my emotional reactions?
Usually I have good luck with rereads and love them more! It is a risk though lol. This was still good at least.
Rereads can be tough. I’ve reread books that I LOVED and when they’e only meh the second time around it hurts sometimes if you have all the good memories lol. Although in thie case it sounds like it was still good, just not the experience it was the first time around? And I can definitely see audio being a part of that if you’re not supr crazy about the narrator… anyway “and everyone was in love” haha yeah that kinda thing can happen fast sometimes, too fast?
Still, glad this is a good one. 🙂
Rereads are risky, but I tend to do well with them mostly. Yep! That’s exactly what this one was, still good, just not as intense, I guess. I do think the audio kinda affected it. Lol so much love all the sudden!
oh well you had me at “dark, intense, and emotional […] heart-wrenching” who wouldn’t want to read something like that??? 🙂 Glad you enjoyed it despite not being a “perfect” audiobook experience 🙂 I’m mostly a plot reader but I can always appreciate a character-driven story that totally sucks you in.
Right? Who doesn’t want books like that? You get me, haha.
It was so interesting to hear how your thoughts have changed and honestly that does happen with books sometimes and it can be a shock to see how much your thoughts turn. I have had that before and sometimes I have some books I consider favourites but don’t necessarily want to reread because I know I won’t like them as much for how much my mind has changed over time 😛 I am glad you could like the romance more this time and understand where it was coming from though ^.^
I feel like I generally have good luck with rereads, though it is always interesting to realize how tastes and perspective can change! Thanks, I did still enjoy this one 🙂
Pingback: Anyone Hungry? How About a BURRITO BOOK TAG? - The Literary Phoenix