Book Review: Black City Demon (Black City Saint Book 2) by Richard A. Knaak

Nick is trying to go back to business as usual with his duty as the Gate to Feirie's guardian, but then peculiar murders start happening, gangsters with magic start targeting Nick, and Nick discovers information about one of Claryce's past incarnations he never knew. Something sinister is once again threatening both the Feirie and human worlds, and Nick and his crew must stop it, but first he will have to figure out what pieces of information he's missing and keep control of the dragon inside who seems to be growing stronger.

Book Review: Black City Demon (Black City Saint Book 2) by Richard A. Knaak | reading, books, book reviews, fantasy, paranormal/urban fantasy, historical fantasy, faeries/fae, dragons, prohibition era
Title: Black City Demon
Book Number: Book 2
Pages: 363
My Rating: 4 Stars
More Info: Goodreads, Amazon, Publisher


I feel like my review is going to be somewhat repetitive since I liked all the same things that I did about the first book, except I liked this one even more.

I once again really liked the combination of the Prohibition Era, Catholicism, Feirie, and dragons (Nick is Saint George, forced to be something close to immortal and guard the Gate to Feirie after slaying the dragon that was guarding it before, as well as forced to share his body with the dragon). It’s just so interesting and meshed together in a way that works really well without feeling cluttered. And the Prohibition Era setting isn’t just an arbitrary background, the author really uses it in the story.

But what made me enjoy this one even more than the last was that the characters shined more. I feel like I got more from Nick this time, more depth, more personality, more emotion. Not all of it was good, but I don’t mean that in a bad way. I just mean that he’s a good guy, but he’s got flaws, and I like that. Or maybe I just noticed more or understood him better this time for some reason. But regardless, instead of dry, I could see that he’s actually just very disenchanted and, as Fetch said, hard-boiled. And I can’t really blame him after everything he’s witnessed and experienced. He also holds grudges, pushes people away, and gets frustrated often—but that’s another thing I can hardly blame him for since he does have a lot of frustrating things to deal with, like his so-called loyal followers keeping information from him, the enigmatic queen of Feirie and her servants who constantly speak in riddles, the mysterious Michael who seems to have a hand in many things but never gives a solid answer about it, a dragon who pretty much uses every opportunity and weakness possible to try and take control of the body they share, and, well, just Fetch in general sometimes. I feel like Nick even had a bit of character growth, realizing that he’s not alone, that it’s ok to rely on his friends for help. And however hard-boiled he may be, Nick cares about people, especially those he’s close to, like Claryce and Fetch.

“Sounds like quite a blow they’re going to. . . .”
I held back a growl. “I meant about Michael.
“He’s going to a meadow with his son. That sounds like a nice time, Master Nicholas. Could we go to a meadow sometime?”
“Are you sure you aren’t really a dog?”

Speaking of Fetch though, I can’t say he’s my favorite character, he has issues following instructions, plus there was the thing that happened in Book 1, but Nick is actually kind of harsh toward him. Nick gets frustrated when Fetch acts like a dog and does dog things, but then he forbids him from doing human things or going too close to humans and makes Fetch live on dumpster rats because he doesn’t even want him eating human food. Poor Fetch can’t win no matter what he does. And really I can’t blame him for wanting to eat good food or listen to sports on the radio or get any sort of enjoyment out life. I mean, the poor creature can’t even speak in human language to anyone unless Nick is near since he’s stuck in a kind of canine form. That’s not a complaint about the book though, just some of my thoughts.

As for Claryce, she still didn’t seem to have much depth beyond her feistiness and stubbornness, but I did once again love how she always jumped in to help when they ended up in a fight instead of cowering and letting Nick get hurt.

And the dragon was still his usual, fascinating, entertaining self. I just can’t bring myself to dislike him, even if he does continually try to take over Nick’s body. I love the dragon’s terrible commentary on things and the hidden conversations they have inside Nick’s mind.

[I] could scare the truth out of him, if you let me . . . or we could perhaps burn him a little . . . just a little, I promise . . . .

I did find the mystery and all the magic surrounding it to be kind of complicated and confusing though. I didn’t quite understand all the connections or what exactly was happening in every scene near the end. That could’ve just been a “me” issue though since I do get confused easily in books with intricate mysteries/plots/magics. And I still understood plenty to enjoy the story.

So overall, I really enjoyed this book! The characters continued to grow me, and, much like the first, this was an interesting and perfectly blended combination of Feirie, Catholicism, dragons, the Prohibition Era, mystery, and magic!


Book Tags:

Basic Info

Book Author:
Genre: , ,
My Rating:

More Info (Possible Spoilers)


Talk to me!

Have you read Black City Saint by Richard A. Knaak?
Do you ever like characters you feel like you probably shouldn't?


Your Thoughts


14 thoughts on “Book Review: Black City Demon (Black City Saint Book 2) by Richard A. Knaak

I'd love if you'd share your thoughts, too!


Reading your comments makes me a very happy blogger!

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *

  1. Wattle

    Hooray for good second books ๐Ÿ™‚ I love characters that have flaws, they seem so much more real when they’re not moody and perfect. It sounds like the series has a unique and cool blend of things going for it.

  2. Lily B

    I think I would adore Nick his character sounds complex, but in a realistic kind of way – if he has went through a lot of stuff in his life.
    Thought not sure how I would feel about Claryce still lacking depth since it’s book 2.

    1. Kristen Burns

      He is a realistically flawed/complex character, and I like that too. The Claryce thing is a little frustrating, but I enjoy enough other things about the book to be able to overlook that.

  3. Bookworm Brandee

    I admit you have me curious. There are so many unique elements…and they’re all meshed together. I just checked and my library has Black City Saint so I’m thinking I’ll give it a go. ๐Ÿ™‚

  4. Dragonfly @ Our Familiarium

    I think you are going to make me read this series! with dragons, faerie and all! LOL I’m intrigued about the mix of Prohibition Era and Catholicism! All the complex magic mystery thingy worries me since I can get easily confused too ๐Ÿ™‚

    1. Kristen Burns

      YAY. You would face your dislike of faeries because of me?! I’m flattered ๐Ÿ˜‰ It is a really intriguing mix of things. Haha, I’m glad to know I’m not the only easily confused person!